If I could erase one movie from my memory and watch it again for the first time, the answer is easy.
Specifically, the 2005 version with Keira Knightley, Matthew Macfadyen, and the rest of that unforgettable cast.
With the film recently reaching its 20th anniversary, I have been thinking about why it still feels so alive.
I know people have their favorite versions of this story. Some are loyal to the BBC version. Some prefer the book above all else, and honestly, I respect that. Jane Austen gave the world something that keeps echoing because she understood people. She understood pride, longing, judgment, class, misunderstanding, restraint, vulnerability, and the quiet wars people fight inside themselves.
The 2005 version captured that so beautifully. The glances. The restraint. The hand flex after Darcy helps Elizabeth into the carriage. Those tiny, wordless moments say so much because they show what people cannot yet bring themselves to say.
She captured the human tug-of-war of her own time so well that we can still hear it today.
That is part of the magic.
But for me, the 2005 movie is the one.
It was a movie I first watched with my mother, and we both fell in love with it. I cannot fully explain what it meant to her or how it landed in her own life journey, but I know what it became for me. It became one of those films I returned to again and again until it felt less like a movie and more like a place.
I have watched it so many times over the years that I can recite nearly every line.
That is not casual enjoyment.
That is love.
And maybe that is why this prompt feels so easy. If I could erase one movie from my memory, it would not be because I want to lose it. It would be because I would love the chance to discover it again.
To feel that first pull.
That first ache.
That first little spark of, “Oh. This is going to stay with me.”
And funny enough, the movie stayed with me in ways I never could have predicted.
After my first marriage, I said I would never marry again. I meant it, too. Then in my early twenties, I had a best friend who was gay and felt similarly about marriage, and we joked about getting married someday. At the time, my last name was Fisher and his was Price, and I thought it would be hilarious to become a doctor and hyphenate the name.
Dr. Fisher-Price.
You never know. I could have been the best pediatrician.
There may have even been a ring exchanged, but we were never serious. It was one of those sweet, strange, funny memories from a younger version of life, before we really understood how many turns the road would take.
Then I swore I would only marry for money.
Do not judge me.
I kind of hated men for a while.
But then I met the Cookie Monster.
And everything changed.
My husband is a truck driver, and Cookie Monster was his handle. I had always been Cherry or CherryCookies online, so when I saw Cookie Monster, it only made sense to reach out. CherryCookies meeting Cookie Monster? Come on. That is funny. That is practically internet destiny.
What I did not know then was that this funny little moment would turn into a life.
We are now 21 years into a journey that has been amazing on so many levels. I could never touch all of what this man has changed in my life in one blog post. There is too much history now. Too much growth. Too many storms we have survived together. Too much love that has become deeper, steadier, and more real with time.
But here is where Pride & Prejudice comes back in.
I met him around the time that movie came out.
And when we got married, I walked into that chapter of my life with music from the movie.
Dramatic?
Maybe.
Worth it.
The song I chose was from that unforgettable dance scene, “A Postcard to Henry Purcell,” where Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy are on the dance floor and the whole room fades away until it is only them. Everyone else disappears. The noise disappears. The pressure disappears. The world disappears.
Just two people.
Seeing each other.
That scene has always been beautiful to me.
And at that moment in my own life, it felt true.
Did I marry for money?
No.
I married for love.
Real love.
Messy love.
Complicated love.
The kind of love that changes the shape of your life.
My husband accepted my son into his world, and in 2010, we welcomed our son together. With complicated histories and blended-family realities, his lovely daughters became part of the story too.
That is probably why Pride & Prejudice still speaks to me after all these years. It is romantic, yes, but not in a shallow way. It is about perception. It is about people misreading each other. It is about class, pride, fear, family pressure, social expectations, and the courage it takes to look again.
To reconsider.
To soften.
To admit that maybe your first impression was not the whole truth.
And isn’t that life?
We think we know what we will never do.
We think we know who we will never love.
We think we know what kind of future we are willing to accept.
Then life walks in wearing a completely unexpected face and says, “Are you sure?”
For me, it was Cookie Monster.
For Elizabeth Bennet, it was Mr. Darcy.
Different story.
Same little miracle.
And I am still here, loving the movie, loving the memory of watching it with my mother, and loving the unexpected life that grew around it.
So yes, if I could erase one movie from my memory and watch it again for the first time, it would be Pride & Prejudice.
Not because I want to forget it.
Because I would love to fall in love with it all over again.
And maybe, in some ways, I still do every time I watch it.
YouTube Fab Five: Clifton Chilli Club
Read More >